Evidence Series — Scottish Energy Compact — November 2026

When the
Wind Stops
The “Green” Claim

Scotland’s data centre pipeline is sold as “green” because Scotland makes a lot of renewable electricity over a year. Data centres don’t run on a year. They run every half-hour, day and night. On Sunday 8 November 2026, wind and solar supplied 5% of Britain’s electricity. Gas supplied two-thirds. This is what “green” means when the wind stops.

5.2%
Wind + solar share of GB electricity, Sunday 8 November 2026
1.6 GW
Average output of every wind farm and solar panel in Britain that day
9.7 GW
Data centre pipeline Scottish Enterprise says it is aware of — six times that output
£204
Average wholesale price per MWh that day — nearly double the year’s £105 average

Section 1 — The Weekend the Wind Stopped

6–8 November 2026: Britain Ran on Gas

In the last week of October, wind and solar were supplying more than half of Britain’s electricity. Twelve days later they were supplying one-twentieth. Across Sunday 8 November, the entire British wind fleet — onshore and offshore, Scotland included — averaged 672MW. Add every solar panel in the country and the total was 1.6GW. In the worst half-hour, wind and solar together produced 321MW.

Gas filled the gap, running at around 21GW — two-thirds of all supply. The wholesale price averaged £201–£232 per MWh across the three days, against £105 for the year as a whole.

Now set the pipeline against it. The proposed data centre at Auchtertool in Fife alone would need 600MW, around the clock — close to everything Britain’s wind farms produced that Sunday, and nearly double what wind and solar managed in the worst half-hour. The 9,714MW pipeline Scottish Enterprise confirmed to us under Freedom of Information is nearly six times the output of every wind turbine and solar panel in the country that day.

None of these facilities would have switched off that weekend. Every megawatt they drew would have come from gas.

Elexon settlement data, 6–8 November 2026

Share of GB electricity supply, by day

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%26 Oct28 Oct30 Oct1 Nov3 Nov5 Nov7 Nov8 Nov5.2%65.6%
Wind + solarGas
Fri 6 NovSat 7 NovSun 8 Nov
Wind + solar share10.9%6.5%5.2%
Gas share59.5%65.5%65.6%
Wind + solar, average output3.7 GW2.0 GW1.6 GW
Wholesale price, average (£/MWh)£232£201£204

Source: Elexon BMRS — generation by fuel type (FUELHH), wind and solar outturn including embedded generation estimates (AGWS), market index price (MID). Great Britain-wide. Shares are of total supply including net imports.

Section 2 — What “Green” Means

In Scottish Enterprise’s Own Evidence, “Green” Means Nothing Measurable

At internal review, Scottish Enterprise released four reports it commissioned or contributed to. Not one sets a measurable threshold for what makes a data centre “green”.

Farrpoint, in its Green Data Centre Study for Scottish Enterprise, defines a green data centre simply as one that draws its power from renewable sources — then states that the market assumes all new data centres will, in effect, be green. A label that applies to everything filters out nothing.

The same study argues any data centre in Scotland could obtain its energy from 100% renewable sources, because Scotland generates close to its annual demand from renewables. That is an annual accounting total. It says nothing about what is on the wires on a still Sunday in November.

Frazer-Nash, commissioned by SE in 2026, says there is no universally agreed definition, and lists environmental assessment as out of scope. AECOM’s 2026 waste-heat review for SE recommends that the Government define “Green Data Centres” in NPF4 — confirmation that no definition exists today.

“The Government’s definition of a green data centre is one that has been approved with due account taken of the environmental implications.”

First Minister John Swinney, FMQs, 18 June 2026

The First Minister’s definition is circular. Scottish Enterprise’s consultants offer no threshold. The Planning Hub confirmed under FOI that the definition “remains under active consideration”. Meanwhile, applications for more than 9GW of capacity are moving through the system under a label nobody can measure.

Reports released by Scottish Enterprise at internal review, 6 November 2026 — see Investigations. Farrpoint, Green Data Centre Study: Initial Baseline Report; Frazer-Nash Consultancy, Socio-economic Assessment of Green Data Centres in Scotland (May 2026); AECOM & HermeticaBlack, Waste Heat from Data Centres (2026).

Section 3 — Who Pays When the Wind Stops

Constant Demand Lands on the Most Expensive Hours

Britain’s wholesale electricity price is set by the last, most expensive generator needed to meet demand. When the wind drops, that is almost always gas. Every household pays that price through the price cap, which follows wholesale costs.

We ranked every half-hour of the past year by how much of Britain’s electricity came from wind and solar. In the least windy tenth of the year, the wholesale price averaged £124/MWh. In the windiest tenth, £48. A data centre draws the same power in both. It cannot wait for the wind.

In still conditions, the extra power comes from gas or, when there is any to buy, from imports. And Britain already leans on imports. Over the past year it imported 41.7TWh and exported 16.4TWh — a net 25.3TWh, about 9% of all the electricity it used, most of it French nuclear and Norwegian hydro. The “Scottish renewable surplus” sits inside a country that is a net importer of electricity.

Scottish Enterprise’s 9.7GW pipeline, running at typical data centre utilisation, would consume roughly 75TWh a year — about three times Britain’s entire net imports. There is no idle surplus waiting to be used. Every megawatt-hour has to come from new generation, more imports, or more gas.

And imports are least available when they are most needed. Across the year, net imports in the least windy tenth of half-hours averaged around 3GW. Last weekend, at the lowest wind of the year, they were roughly zero: neighbouring countries had little to spare, and gas did all the work.

Least windy tenth of the year
£124 / MWh

Average wholesale price when wind and solar supplied about 5% of electricity.

Windiest tenth of the year
£48 / MWh

Average wholesale price when wind and solar supplied about 70% of electricity.

Elexon BMRS half-hourly data, 9 November 2025 – 8 November 2026 (17,520 settlement periods). Wholesale price = APX market index price. Over the full year, wind and solar supplied 37% of GB electricity, gas 27% and net imports 9%.

Britain’s interconnectors, 12 monthsTWh
Imported41.7
Exported16.4
Net imports25.3
of which from France (IFA, IFA2, ElecLink)21.5 imported
of which from Norway (North Sea Link)7.7 imported
Data centre pipeline at typical utilisation~75 a year

Elexon BMRS interconnector flows (FUELHH), 9 November 2025 – 8 November 2026. Pipeline consumption assumes 9,714MW at around 85–90% average utilisation.

Section 4 — The Case For, Answered

The Strongest Arguments for “Green” Data Centres — and Why They Fall Short

“Scotland wastes wind. Data centres would use it.”

The best argument the industry has — and it is partly right.

Scotland does switch off huge amounts of wind because the grid cannot carry it south. In 2025, turning down Scottish wind cost around £350 million, and replacement generation — mostly gas — cost over £1 billion. Demand located north of the bottleneck could absorb some of that.

But curtailment happens when it is windy. A data centre runs at full load when it is still, too. Absorbing surplus wind for part of the year does not make a facility green on 8 November. Only flexible demand — load that genuinely ramps down when the wind does — solves the problem. SE’s own consultants, Frazer-Nash, describe data centres as inherently inflexible. If developers claim the curtailment benefit, they should be required to prove the flexibility.

“Add batteries: the surplus wind would charge them.”

Storage north of the bottleneck would genuinely reduce curtailment — independent analysis suggests the planned long-duration storage sites could avoid around 40% of it.

The difficulty is that the same surplus cannot be used twice. Curtailed wind across Britain came to just under 10TWh in 2025 — an average of about 1.1GW. A 9.7GW pipeline running continuously north of the constraint would absorb that surplus directly, almost every hour it occurs, leaving little or nothing over to charge batteries. The batteries would then be charged from the ordinary grid, adding to demand rather than using spare power.

The volumes and timing also differ. All of Britain’s curtailed wind would cover about 13% of the pipeline’s annual consumption of roughly 75TWh. The surplus arrives in windy spells; storage is needed in still ones. Much of the curtailment also occurs in northern Scotland, not necessarily where Central Belt sites are proposed.

The reduction in constraint payments is a real benefit of locating demand north of the bottleneck, and should be counted. But it can be counted once: either the surplus lowers constraint costs by powering the data centres, or it fills the batteries — not both.

“Scotland is nearly 100% renewable.”

Over a year, on paper. The same still weather that stopped Britain’s turbines stopped Scotland’s, and Scotland is tied to English gas generation through the grid. An annual total is not a supply on the wires at 6pm on a calm Sunday.

“Operators buy renewable power contracts.”

A power purchase agreement matches megawatt-hours over a year on paper. On 8 November, the wind farm in the contract was not turning. The facility drew power anyway, and it came from gas. The honest test is hourly: was renewable power actually being generated, in every hour, to match what the facility used?

“Imports will fill the gap.”

Sometimes, at a price. Still weather often covers north-west Europe at once. Last weekend Britain’s interconnectors were roughly in balance. When imports do flow, Britain pays the British price for them — and the British price in still weather is set by gas.

“You picked the worst weekend.”

Yes — deliberately. Only two days in the past year fell below 10% wind and solar; 35 fell below 20%. But a facility that runs every hour must be supplied in the worst hour, not the average one. The system has to keep gas capacity on standby for that week, and consumers pay for that standby all year round.

Section 5 — What Would It Take?

Battery Storage for One Day of the Pipeline

One way to keep a facility running on stored renewable power through a still spell is battery storage. We estimated what it would take for the full 9,714MW pipeline Scottish Enterprise identified to run for 24 hours from batteries alone.

Running at full load, the pipeline uses about 233GWh a day. Batteries cannot be fully discharged and lose some energy in charging and discharging, so around 260GWh of installed capacity would be required. At current utility-scale costs of roughly £75–£150 per kWh — the lower figure for longer-duration systems — that is in the region of £20–40 billion. Battery systems typically last 15–20 years.

For scale, Britain’s entire grid battery fleet stood at 14.4GWh at the end of September 2026. Together with existing pumped hydro, all current storage in Great Britain would run the pipeline for around four hours.

Two further points apply. The still spell of 6–8 November lasted three days, not one. And stored energy has to be replaced from surplus generation, which is limited during the low-wind periods when storage is drawn on.

For comparison, Scottish Enterprise’s own economic model puts the build cost of a 50MW data hall at £430 million — around £83 billion for the full pipeline.

One day of storage for the pipelineEstimate
Energy to run 9,714MW for 24 hours233 GWh
Installed battery capacity required~260 GWh
Indicative cost at £75–£150/kWh£20–40bn
Existing and planned storage, Great Britain
Grid battery fleet, Q3 202614.4 GWh
Pumped hydro (four sites)~24 GWh
Coire Glas pumped hydro (planned)~46 GWh
Hours of pipeline demand covered by all existing storage~4 hours

Battery costs: Modo Energy global capex survey, September 2026 (4-hour median US$201k/MWh); Ember via Carbon Commentary, July 2026 (around £75–95/kWh for longer-duration systems). Fleet size: Modo Energy GB buildout report, Q3 2026. Pumped hydro and Coire Glas: Carbon Commentary, July 2026. Assumes full load, ~90% usable capacity and efficiency, £1 = US$1.30. At typical utilisation of 85–90%, requirements fall by around a tenth. Data hall cost: Scottish Enterprise, Green Data Centres: Approach to Estimating Economic Impact (February 2025).

Under Compact Condition 1, each developer would choose and fund its own firm supply — storage, gas or another source — rather than relying on the wider system. These figures indicate the scale of that choice if storage were the route taken.

Section 6 — A Reality Check

Green Data Centres in Scotland: A Reality Check

Take the still weekend of 6–8 November 2026 and add 20 large data centres running in Scotland — about 10GW, close to the 9,714MW pipeline Scottish Enterprise has confirmed. Running around the clock, they use about 233GWh a day: around 700GWh across the three days.

10GW of data centresDemandSupplied by
Day 1233 GWhBatteries — only if £20–40bn of storage had been built. None exists today.
Day 2233 GWhThe grid, with gas meeting the extra demand
Day 3233 GWhThe grid, with gas meeting the extra demand
After the spell~260 GWhThe grid again, to refill the batteries

What the grid ran on that weekend: gas around 65%, nuclear 16%, biomass 10%, wind and solar 6%, net imports close to zero. Nuclear stations were already running flat out and cannot raise output to meet new demand. Imports did not arrive, despite prices above £200/MWh. Every extra megawatt would have come from gas.

The margin: an extra 10GW of round-the-clock demand would sit on top of normal winter demand. NESO’s forecast spare margin for winter 2026/27 is 5.5GW.

The cost: with no storage, 700GWh at that weekend’s wholesale prices comes to about £150m of power, mostly gas-fired. With one day of batteries, days two and three still come to about £95–100m. Data centres in Scotland’s AI Growth Zones are also in line for an electricity discount of up to £24/MWh from April 2027 — see Grid Costs.

The gas fleet: NESO notes that many of today’s gas plants were commissioned before 2000 and may approach retirement by the early 2030s. One industry analysis puts the net retirement risk at about 12GW of firm capacity — roughly the size of the pipeline.

Who would pay for £40bn of batteries?

Developers are not required to build storage. Britain’s scheme for long-duration storage, run by Ofgem, guarantees projects a revenue floor. If revenues fall below it, the shortfall is recovered through network charges on electricity bills — not through taxes. If revenues exceed a cap, the surplus is returned the same way, and Ofgem expects payments to be broadly neutral over time.

Unless developers are required to pay for their own backup, the default route for storage on this scale runs through bills.

What if Britain doubled its wind turbines?

Britain has over 20GW of offshore wind and 16.4GW onshore. Doubling it means building about 37GW more.

6–8 Nov mixActualDouble wind
Wind2.9%5.8%
Solar2.9%2.9%
Wind + solar5.8%8.7%
Gas~65%~63%

Turbines alone: roughly £65–110bn. Transmission on top: the current GB grid programme, built for existing plans, is put at up to £70bn by the National Audit Office, and a doubled fleet would need new lines on a similar scale. More turbines add little on a still weekend, because the same weather stills them all.

Generation mix and prices: Elexon BMRS, 6–8 November 2026. Margin: NESO Winter Outlook 2026/27. Storage funding: Ofgem LDES cap and floor regime. Gas retirement: NESO Resource Adequacy in the 2030s; Watt-Logic (November 2025). Wind fleet and costs: RenewableUK; IRENA; NREL; National Audit Office (September 2026). Assumes full load, ~90% usable battery capacity, £1 = US$1.30.

Section 7 — What Scotland Should Demand

If It Is Green, Prove It — Every Hour

“Green” should be a test a facility passes, not a word on a planning application. Compact Condition 1 already requires every facility above 200MW to secure firm, dispatchable power for 100% of its demand, at its own cost, before consent. The evidence of 6–8 November is why.

Any facility seeking the “green” label — and any subsidy that comes with it — should have to show, hour by hour, where its power will come from when the wind stops, and who pays for it.

COMPACT CONDITION 1 — FIRM POWER

A contracted pathway to firm, dispatchable supply for 100% of maximum demand, at full cost-reflective charges, with no grid, capacity or balancing costs socialised onto households.

A MEASURABLE DEFINITION OF “GREEN”

No facility to be described as “green” in planning policy unless it publishes hour-by-hour matching of its consumption against renewable generation, with Power Usage Effectiveness and Water Usage Effectiveness targets as conditions of consent — measures SE’s own consultants recommend.

Method & Sources

Generation, interconnector and price data: Elexon Balancing Mechanism Reporting Service (data.elexon.co.uk), datasets FUELHH, AGWS and MID, every settlement period from 9 November 2025 to 8 November 2026. Wind and solar output uses AGWS, which includes NESO estimates for smaller embedded wind and solar not metered at transmission level. Total supply is estimated as transmission generation plus embedded wind and solar plus net interconnector flows. Solar figures are missing for around 4% of half-hours, mostly overnight. All figures are Great Britain-wide; half-hourly generation is not published separately for Scotland.

Curtailment costs: Modo Energy, March 2026. Curtailment volume and storage estimates: Carbon Commentary, July 2026. Winter margin: NESO Winter Outlook 2026/27. Storage funding: Ofgem, long duration electricity storage. Gas fleet retirement risk: Watt-Logic, November 2025. Transmission programme: National Audit Office, September 2026. Pipeline capacity: Scottish Enterprise FOI response, 23 September 2026. Reports on “green” data centres: released by Scottish Enterprise at internal review, 6 November 2026 — links on our Investigations page.

Green Is a Test, Not a Label

The Compact asks developers to prove where their power comes from when the wind stops — and to pay for it themselves.

Read the Compact → Write to your MSP