Active Investigations
The Scottish Energy Compact is using the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 to establish what public money has been spent promoting Scotland as a hyperscale data centre destination, and whether any cumulative assessment of energy, water and grid impact was conducted before that promotion began. The full text of each request is published below. Responses will be published here as they are received.
Scottish Futures Trust is a Scottish Government company funded by approximately £8.2 million per year of public money. It established and ran the Host in Scotland programme, which identified and promoted 12 data centre sites across Scotland to international hyperscale operators — without any published cumulative assessment of the energy, water or grid impact of those developments.
Key Findings
To: Freedom of Information Officer
Scottish Futures Trust Limited
1 Atlantic Quay, 1 Robertson Street, Glasgow, G2 8JB
foi@scottishfuturestrust.org.uk
Subject: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 — Request for Information: Host in Scotland Programme
Dear Freedom of Information Officer,
I write to request the following information under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002.
1. Expenditure
Please provide a full breakdown of all expenditure relating to the Host in Scotland programme from its inception to the date of this request, including but not limited to:
2. Impact Assessment
Please provide copies of all internal or commissioned assessments conducted prior to, or during, the promotion of identified data centre sites, relating to:
3. Ministerial Direction
Please provide all correspondence between Scottish Futures Trust and Scottish Ministers relating to the establishment, funding and objectives of the Host in Scotland programme.
4. Due Diligence
Please confirm whether any cumulative impact assessment was conducted before the 12 shortlisted sites were publicly identified and promoted to the international data centre market. If such an assessment was conducted, please provide a copy. If no such assessment was conducted, please confirm this in writing.
I would be grateful to receive this information within the statutory 20 working days. If any information is withheld, please specify the exemption relied upon and confirm whether the public interest test has been applied.
Yours faithfully,
Michael Knox
Scottish Energy Compact
scottishenergycompact.co.uk
To: Michael Knox
mike.knoxy@icloud.com
6 July 2026
Re: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act Request for Information Dated 18 June 2026
Dear Mr Knox
I refer to your request for information dated 18 June 2026 ("Your Request"). Information relevant to Your Request is as follows:
Host in Scotland was an initiative to represent and promote the interests of the Scottish datacentre and subsea sector industry. Host in Scotland was started in 2017 by Scottish Futures Trust and the initiative has not been active since 2023. Since the publication of the Scottish Government's Green Datacentre Vision and Action Plan in March 2021, any datacentre work has been run by the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise.
In March 2021, Scottish Futures Trust, together with Crown Estate Scotland and Scottish Enterprise, published a report listing sites across Scotland potentially suitable for datacentre locations. The site selection report was written and produced for SFT by consultancy firm TechRe, in parallel with the Scottish Government's Green Datacentres and Digital Connectivity Vision and Action Plan. The report identifies that datacentre operators and other interested parties would need to undertake their own site investigations and risk assessments to satisfy themselves of the suitability of a specific location.
1. Expenditure
Staff costs and time allocation — In accordance with section 17(1) of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, SFT does not hold this information. The Host in Scotland initiative formed the majority of a full-time role for an employee from mid-2017 to mid-2023, supported by a part-time role from July 2021 to March 2023. Employees were at Associate Director grade, salary band (2022/23) £51,700–£86,700.
External consultancy fees, including FarrPoint and TechRE — Provided in full. See the consultancy expenditure breakdown below.
Marketing and promotional activity — 10 Host in Scotland in-person events were hosted in Edinburgh or Glasgow. Expenditure across these events (excluding consultancy already captured above) totalled £15,807.
Site identification and assessment costs — In accordance with section 17(1), SFT does not hold this information separately; costs incurred by external consultants relating to this are encompassed within the consultancy fees breakdown below.
Travel and hospitality — Travel and accommodation for attendance at datacentre and international connectivity meetings and conferences (including Dublin, London, Amsterdam, Monaco and New Orleans) totalled £12,602. All other incidental expenses totalled £3,931.
Expenditure promoting identified sites to international operators — In accordance with section 17(1), SFT does not hold this information.
SFT holds information falling within the scope of this request from 1 April 2019 onwards only. Information created prior to this date is held in archive storage and was not searched for the purposes of this response.
| Description | Company | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-current financial system — reports produced: | ||
| Scottish DC Location Review, Jan 2018 | CBRE | £45,000.00 |
| Economic impact of international connectivity and data centre development, Sept 2018 | Deloitte | £101,700.00 |
| Economic impact of international connectivity and data centre development, Jan 2018 | Gartner | £59,998.80 |
| Financial records, 2019–2023 (TechRE were a sub-consultant to Farrpoint from Mar 2020–Jun 2023): | ||
| HIS workshop invoices | TechRe Consulting | £11,997.56 |
| Data centre site consultancy, visits, review resource (20 invoices, Mar 2020–Nov 2023) | Farrpoint Limited | £180,069.78 |
| Total consultancy expenditure | £398,766.14 | |
2. Impact Assessment
SFT confirms that no internal or commissioned assessments were conducted relating to cumulative energy demand on the Scottish grid, water abstraction and consumption requirements, environmental impact, cost to Scottish electricity consumers, or grid reinforcement requirements and associated costs.
3. Ministerial Direction
SFT confirms that there is no such correspondence between itself and Scottish Ministers.
4. Due Diligence
SFT confirms that no cumulative impact assessments were conducted before the 12 shortlisted sites were publicly identified and promoted to the international data centre market.
If you are unhappy with this response, you may ask that Scottish Futures Trust carries out an internal review by writing to the Chief Executive, Peter Reekie. If you are unhappy with the outcome of the internal review, you have the right to appeal to the Scottish Information Commissioner.
Yours sincerely,
Paul Moseley
Senior Associate Director (Legal & Commercial), Scottish Futures Trust
Download full response letter (PDF) · Download consultancy expenditure breakdown (PDF)
Scottish Enterprise is Scotland's main economic development agency, funded by Scottish Government. It took over the Host in Scotland programme from Scottish Futures Trust and has actively marketed Scotland to international hyperscale data centre operators through Scottish Development International and Scotland IS — spending public money to attract developments whose cumulative impact on Scotland's energy system and household bills has never been publicly assessed.
Key Findings
Internal Review Outcome — 6 November 2026
What the Appendices Show
Appendices released by Scottish Enterprise at internal review (redacted by SE):
Reports released by Scottish Enterprise at internal review:
To: Freedom of Information Officer
Scottish Enterprise
Atrium Court, 50 Waterloo Street, Glasgow, G2 6HQ
foi@scottishenterprise.com
Subject: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 — Request for Information: Data Centre Promotion and Inward Investment Activity
Dear Freedom of Information Officer,
I write to request the following information under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002.
1. Expenditure
Please provide a full breakdown of all expenditure by Scottish Enterprise relating to the promotion of Scotland as a data centre location, from 2020 to the date of this request, including:
2. Operators Engaged
Please provide a list of all hyperscale or large-scale data centre operators that Scottish Enterprise has formally engaged with, hosted, or provided information to as part of its data centre inward investment activity.
3. Impact Assessment
Please provide copies of all assessments conducted by Scottish Enterprise, or commissioned on its behalf, relating to:
4. Co-ordination with Other Bodies
Please provide all correspondence between Scottish Enterprise and the following bodies relating to data centre promotion and site identification:
5. Pipeline Knowledge
As of the date of this request, please confirm the total megawatt capacity of data centre developments in Scotland that Scottish Enterprise is aware of, whether consented, under construction or in planning.
I would be grateful to receive this information within the statutory 20 working days. If any information is withheld, please specify the exemption relied upon and confirm whether the public interest test has been applied.
Yours faithfully,
Michael Knox
Scottish Energy Compact
scottishenergycompact.co.uk
To: foi@scottishenterprise.com
25 July 2026
Subject: Overdue Response — Freedom of Information Request Dated 18 June 2026
Dear Freedom of Information Officer,
I am writing to follow up on my Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 request submitted on 18 June 2026, regarding data centre promotion and inward investment activity by Scottish Enterprise (subject: "Data Centre Promotion and Inward Investment Activity").
Under Section 10 of the Act, a response was due within 20 working days, which fell on 16 July 2026. That deadline has now passed without a response or any acknowledgement of extension.
Please provide the requested information as a matter of urgency, or confirm the current status of my request. If a response is not received within 5 working days of this email, I will consider referring this matter to the Scottish Information Commissioner for a failure to respond within the statutory timescale.
For reference, my original request sought:
Yours faithfully,
Michael Knox
Scottish Energy Compact
scottishenergycompact.co.uk
To: FOI@scotent.co.uk
25 July 2026
Subject: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 — Request for Information: Data Centre Promotion and Inward Investment Activity (Resubmission)
Dear Freedom of Information Officer,
I originally submitted this request under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 on 18 June 2026, sent to foi@scottishenterprise.com. I have since discovered that address does not accept mail, and both that request and a follow-up sent on 25 July 2026 were never delivered. I am therefore resubmitting the original request in full below, to this correct address.
Please provide the following information:
I would be grateful to receive this information within the statutory 20 working days from the date of this email. If any information is withheld, please specify the exemption relied upon and confirm whether the public interest test has been applied.
Yours faithfully,
Michael Knox
Scottish Energy Compact
scottishenergycompact.co.uk
To: Michael Knox
mike.knoxy@icloud.com
23 September 2026
Re: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 Request
Dear Mr Knox
Thank you for your information request. We are responding to you under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act (FOISA) 2002.
Response
1. Expenditure — Scottish Enterprise's formal position is that it does not promote data centres or undertake any proactive lead generation or marketing of Scotland as a destination for potential green data centre investment. Instead, our approach is reactive, working with partners and responding to enquiries received, primarily from data centre developers.
2. Operators Engaged — We keep a record of enquiries we have received, however the majority of these have been from developers plus landowners rather than operators. We can advise there is currently one operator/developer on our active list, and two operators on our inactive list, meaning no further engagement or progress was made. We are unable to provide the names of these organisations for reasons of commercial confidentiality, therefore this information is withheld under section 33(1)(b) of FOISA.
Section 33(1)(b) — Substantial prejudice to commercial interests: the exemption has been applied where SE identifies that release of the full information would, or would be likely to, harm the commercial interests of third parties. SE considers there is significant public interest in protecting the legitimate economic interests of companies, and concludes that the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the public interest in avoiding substantial harm to those interests.
3. Impact Assessment — SE has not undertaken assessments of promoted developments. As noted above, SE's formal position is that it does not promote any developments.
4. Co-ordination with Other Bodies — SE has had no named formal structures for the promotion of data centres. Engagement with the Scottish Government and local authorities has generally been focused on responding to investor enquiries and discussing specific project opportunities. SE participates in the Green Data Centre Cross Cutting Working Group led by the Scottish Government, but states this is not intended to actively promote data centres, instead providing a forum for discussion and coordination on policy, infrastructure and wider sector issues.
5. Pipeline Knowledge — On 25 June 2026 an exercise was conducted to establish the total megawatt capacity of proposed data centres from public domain sources and found this to be 9,714 MW. SE stresses that this concerns proposals, meaning many of these developments are at a very early pre-planning stage, do not have grid connections, and are viewed as unlikely to progress.
If you consider that your request has not been handled appropriately you have the right under FOISA to request a review within 40 working days of the date of this letter, addressed to Adrian Gillespie, Chief Executive.
Yours sincerely,
Corporate Communications
Scottish Enterprise
To: Michael Knox
By email
6 November 2026
Dear Mr Knox
Thank you for your request for review of our recent FOI response of 23 September 2026, and apologies for the late issue of my response.
As per section 20(3)(c)(ii) of FOISA, a requirement for review must specify the reason for the applicant's dissatisfaction with the way the public authority has dealt with the information request.
You advised that you are dissatisfied with Scottish Enterprise's response to Points 1 – 4 of your request.
Question 1 – Expenditure
Your original request asked for a breakdown of all expenditure by Scottish Enterprise (SE) relating to the promotion of Scotland as a data centre location from 2020 to date. Our response advised that SE does not promote data centres or undertake any proactive lead generation of marketing of Scotland as a destination for potential green data centre investment.
Your review request states that this should include expenditure in relation to staff time responding to enquiries, attendance at Host in Scotland events and any marketing collateral produced, even if on a reactive model of engagement.
We do not have records or processes which would allow us to estimate expenditure of staff time responding to enquiries or attending events, therefore, Section 17 (Information not held) is applied.
We have identified an email which is included in Appendix 1 which relates to SE's contribution to a piece of work Scottish Futures Trust commissioned on data centre site selection. Names and contact details of individuals have been redacted and withheld under Section 38(1)(b) of FOISA. Information on how the exemption has been applied is included at the end of this letter.
Question 2 – Application of Section 33(1)(b)
You have asked that the FOI Review considers the application of Section 33(1)(b) in relation to the names of the organisations which SE has engaged with in relation to data centres.
The information held has been sourced through our international investor engagement activity. The nature of the withheld information and the circumstances in which it was provided to SE are such that there is an implied duty of confidentiality. SE must be able to assure the businesses we engage with that sensitive information will not be released as a result of their involvement with SE. We consider that release of this information, which is not in the public domain, would provide insights into the organisations' potential investment interests in Scotland.
The Public Interest test was considered as part of our response to your initial FOI request and was outlined within our response.
I conclude that the exemption and Public Interest test was applied appropriately.
Question 3
Your initial request asked for Impact Assessments of promoted developments. Our response stated that SE has not undertaken assessments of promoted developments. Your subsequent FOI Review asked that SE considers whether any assessments have been commissioned or contributed to under any description of its activity. This has therefore broadened the scope from your original request.
We have identified information which we consider falls within this broader scope and which is included within the links below. These are reports which SE has commissioned or contributed to and which are available on our website.
Question 4 (Co-ordination with Other Bodies)
You requested correspondence with Scottish Futures Trust, Scottish Development International, Scotland IS and the Scottish Government Director for Digital regarding data centre promotion.
The original response advised that SE's engagement with Scottish Government and local authorities has been focused on responding to investor enquiries and discussing specific project opportunities. We also outlined SE's participation in the Green Data Centre Cross Cutting Working Group, as this related to the forum for discussion and coordination across organisations on matters of policy, infrastructure etc.
Your review request clarified that you were also looking for informal contact, ie meetings or internal correspondence. However, relating this back to your original request, this would be specifically in relation to discussing positions to be taken with the bodies listed regarding data centre promotion.
The information included in Appendix 1 also relates to the scope of this question. I have also attached information in Appendix 2 which is also considered to be within scope. The work referenced in Appendix 2 regarding visioning for data centres was not progressed beyond this initial brief. Names and contact details of individuals have been redacted and withheld under Section 38(1)(b) of FOISA.
Your right to apply to the Information Commissioner under FOISA
If you are dissatisfied with the outcome of the review, you have the right under FOISA to apply to the Scottish Information Commissioner within six months following the date of receipt of the review notice.
[The letter closes with Scottish Enterprise's standard explanation of how the section 38(1)(b) personal data exemption was applied to the names and contact details of SE employees. See the PDF for the full text.]
Yours sincerely,
Adrian Gillespie
Chief Executive, Scottish Enterprise
Download full response letter (PDF) · Download internal review response (PDF)
On 18 June 2026 at First Minister's Questions, John Swinney told Parliament that "The Government's planning hub has been working with planning authorities to ensure that there is a wide and consistent understanding" of how to assess data centre applications. On the same day Ross Greer MSP placed on the parliamentary record that six applications in the current pipeline have undergone no environmental impact assessment. This FOI asks the Planning Hub to produce the guidance that the First Minister described — and to confirm whether any definition of "green data centre" with measurable thresholds has ever been issued.
Key Findings
To: Freedom of Information Officer
Scottish Government
foi@gov.scot
Subject: Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 — Request for Information: Scottish Government Planning Hub — Data Centre Guidance
Dear Freedom of Information Officer,
I write to request the following information under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002.
On 18 June 2026, at First Minister's Questions in the Scottish Parliament, the First Minister stated:
"The Government's planning hub has been working with planning authorities to ensure that there is a wide and consistent understanding of those factors when coming to those conclusions."
The factors referred to were renewable energy use, energy-efficient technologies, reduced water consumption and the reuse of excess heat, in the context of assessing applications for hyperscale data centre developments.
I request the following information:
1. Guidance Issued
Please provide all guidance, circulars, letters, briefing notes and communications issued by the Scottish Government Planning Hub to Scottish planning authorities relating to the assessment of hyperscale or large-scale data centre applications, from 1 January 2022 to the date of this request.
2. Environmental Impact Assessment
Please confirm whether the Planning Hub has issued any guidance to planning authorities on the circumstances in which an Environmental Impact Assessment is required for data centre applications. If such guidance exists please provide a copy. If no such guidance has been issued please confirm this in writing.
3. Recipients
Please provide a list of all planning authorities to which the Planning Hub has issued data centre guidance, and the dates on which that guidance was issued.
4. Consistency Assessment
Please provide any internal assessment, report or correspondence produced by the Planning Hub evaluating whether planning authorities are applying a consistent approach to the assessment of data centre applications.
5. Definition
Please provide any internal document in which the Scottish Government has defined the term "green data centre" for the purposes of National Planning Framework 4 Policy 24 or National Development 12, including any minimum thresholds, metrics or standards associated with that definition.
I would be grateful to receive this information within the statutory 20 working days. If any information is withheld, please specify the exemption relied upon and confirm whether the public interest test has been applied.
The public interest in disclosure is substantial. The First Minister made a positive factual assertion to Parliament about the Planning Hub's work. That assertion has been directly contradicted by evidence placed on the parliamentary record the same day. The public has a clear interest in establishing whether the guidance described by the First Minister exists, what it contains and whether it has been consistently applied.
Yours faithfully,
Michael Knox
Scottish Energy Compact
scottishenergycompact.co.uk
To: Michael Knox
17 July 2026
Ref: 202600522802
Re: Environmental Information (Scotland) Regulations 2004 — Your Request Dated 19 June 2026
Thank you for your request. As the information requested is "environmental information," it has been handled under the EIRs rather than FOISA (a technical point with no material effect on the outcome).
1. Guidance Issued
The Scottish Government National Planning Hub (NPH) has not issued formal guidance, circulars, briefing notes or written communications to planning authorities collectively on assessing hyperscale or large-scale data centre applications between 1 January 2022 and the date of the request. One relevant document was identified: a letter from the Chief Planner to City of Edinburgh Council dated 13 May 2026, enclosed with the response. Beyond this, the NPH points to non-written engagement only — a webinar with planning authorities and stakeholders, and a roundtable co-organised with techUK on 18 March 2026 (slide deck enclosed) — describing both as intended "to support knowledge sharing and consistency of understanding, rather than to constitute formal guidance."
2. Environmental Impact Assessment
The NPH has not issued specific guidance on when an EIA is required for data centre applications. This is left to individual planning authorities to determine case-by-case under the Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Scotland) Regulations 2017.
3. Recipients
As no formal data centre-specific guidance has been issued, there is no list of planning authorities or issue dates to provide.
4. Consistency Assessment
The NPH has not produced any internal assessment, report or correspondence evaluating whether planning authorities are applying a consistent approach. The Government states the NPH's role is to support capacity and information-sharing, "rather than to monitor, assess or audit decision-making by planning authorities" — responsibility for consistency rests with individual authorities.
5. Definition
The Scottish Government does not hold any internal document defining "green data centre" for NPF4 Policy 24 or National Development 12, including any minimum thresholds, metrics or standards. The response states this work "remains under active consideration and has not yet been taken forward," and quotes the First Minister in Parliament on 25 June 2026: "I am giving active consideration to whether the Scottish Government should provide planning guidance to balance the rapid expansion of hyperscale data centres with national energy and climate goals, which are vital to our future prosperity."
Yours sincerely,
Scottish Government FOI Unit
Download full response letter (PDF) · Download enclosed Chief Planner letter to Edinburgh Council, 13 May 2026 (PDF) · Download enclosed techUK/Scottish Government roundtable slides, 18 March 2026 (PDF)
Holyrood Evidence
Ross Greer MSP, co-leader of the Scottish Greens, questioned First Minister John Swinney on the Scottish Government's definition of a "green data centre" and called for a moratorium on approvals for hyperscale developments above 50MW. The full exchange is reproduced below in order. This is a matter of public parliamentary record.
Verdict
On 18 June 2026, the First Minister told Parliament the planning hub had already been ensuring a "wide and consistent understanding" of green data centre criteria, and that assessment criteria were "very clearly set out in planning policy." The Scottish Government's own written FOI response, dated 17 July 2026, says otherwise on every count below.
The Timeline That Contradicts the Claim
If you have information relevant to these investigations — or believe there are questions we have not yet asked — we want to hear from you. This includes planning professionals, former public servants, energy industry insiders, academics, journalists and members of the public.
We are particularly interested in:
All sources are treated in confidence unless you indicate otherwise. This is an independent public interest campaign with no political or commercial funding.
Submit Information →